No yeah, joking aside I am totally and 100% okay with this. When and where it happens depends entirely on who gets on the team going into the transporter room to face down with the mutineers holding that space and what they choose to do when they get there but even if it's something that happens technically after the 19th, I am all for this! I know Saul's got anime powers and can probably explode Charlie's face and I'm...also completely fine with that if that's what Saul chooses to do (though Charlie would personally prefer he didn't, js).

As far as this plot goes, I am all about the consequences so if Saul punching Charlie is something you'd like to do: hell yeah, lets make it happen.